Is It People Pleasing Or Is It Survival Mode? Here's Why They're Related, From A Therapist

Difficulty saying “no” to others, not wanting to disappoint, seeking external validation, fear of rejection—these are all common traits of “people pleasing” behaviors. But have you ever stopped to think about the reasons why you people please? Or why you people please when there’s no reason to (like being in a safe environment with friends)?

The fawn response is a survival mechanism and trauma response to potential danger. While our fight or flight responses are associated with active measures to get you to safety, fawning is more passive and submissive. 

When facing a threat, individuals may “fawn” as a way of appeasing the potential threat. Fawning includes compliance, being overly accommodating, and doing whatever it takes to avoid confrontation or “rocking the boat.” Fawning involves keeping the peace. 

The primary purpose of a trauma response is to keep you safe. To keep you alive. To keep you away from threats of danger.  

As a child, a common example of avoiding conflict is not acting out. If a child acts out, this may result in getting punished or disciplined. Getting put into timeout as a child or having your phone temporarily taken away as a teen are normal forms of punishment. 

However, if a child has an age-appropriate temper tantrum, and it is reciprocated with being hit, yelled at, or neglected/ignored, it could cause serious emotional harm to that child. And feeling emotionally insecure does not feel safe for a child—a child cannot survive on its own. If the child learns that “being the good child” or “the one who is always okay” results in less conflict, it may carry with them into adulthood.  

Every child needs to meet the needs of their parents in some way. For example, a parent or caregiver would need to know if their baby is sick, hungry, injured, etc to keep them safe. But how would they know the baby’s needs if the baby cannot communicate?  

In order to get their needs met, the baby would need to figure out what works best for the parent to get their attention. If the baby has a broken joint (which is not visible to the eye for the parent), the baby may try crying—but the parent just sees this as them being hungry. But if the baby cried and grunted every time they rolled on their injured side, that would get the attention of the parent that something may be wrong. In short, the baby had to adjust their behaviors to have their needs met.

If you had a parent who punished you if you didn’t do things the way they wanted, it would affect your well-being. For example, if you had a mother who would “ice you out” if you didn’t constantly validate or comfort them, that would impact your needs. If you didn’t act like your mother’s best friend, it may have resulted in you not getting lunch that day. You feel ignored, dismissed, and not seen.  

The brain loves predictability. And the biggest enemy to the brain (and anxiety) is the unknown, when things are unpredictable. 

When things are lighthearted and easy going, it’s easier to relax. But if there is the potential for conflict, it could activate the nervous system to be ready for an uncomfortable moment to strike at any time. 

Being the mediator to keep fights between family members and friends to a minimum results in a calmer environment. An environment that doesn’t require that “walking on eggshells” feeling. This can look like so many things growing up, such as being the class clown or the butt of the joke, in order to take the focus off the “dangerous” or uncomfortable topic, and bring the room back to safety.  

Have you ever been mad or hurt by someone, and when you bring it up, they blame it entirely on you? Or they saw the situation in a completely different light? It’s confusing, right!? 

Now imagine how confusing that is for a child. When we bring childhood development into the equation, having their “reality” invalidated can feel really overwhelming and scary. Here’s what I mean: 

Let’s say a 5-year old has a tantrum because they lost their favorite stuffed animal. Although it may not seem like a big deal in the grand scheme of things, it certainly is a big deal for the child crying bloody murder because their favorite object has suddenly disappeared from existence.  

If the caregiver’s response is nurturing and understanding, and validates to the child that their emotions are appropriate, it makes the child feel safer because their emotions are accepted. That their emotions match reality and the situation.  

If the caregiver’s response is, “OMG, it’s not a big deal, it was just a dumb toy,” or “Stop crying! You’re being way too sensitive,” it can be really overwhelming. This makes the child think their reality and their emotions do not meet the reality and emotions of the world around them. The ultimate takeaway is the child thinking that their emotions are “wrong.” 

As an adult, you may not feel safe or secure when you’re being invalidated. And your “fawn” response may be activated out of fear of someone’s reaction. It could look like second guessing yourself, and going over scenarios over and over in your head to try to justify your emotions—or to justify the other person’s emotions. 

Recognizing when a trauma response is activated can be really difficult. I often hear clients ask “Why am I like this?” or “What is wrong with me?” In reality there is nothing “wrong” with them. 

The first (and probably most difficult and frustrating) step to reducing the people pleasing fawn response is to acknowledge and be aware when you’re doing it. You can’t fix something if you don’t know it’s there.  

When I feel myself being activated when there’s no danger, I will talk to my nervous system. Literally. I say something like, “Hey nervous system, I see you, I feel you. And I appreciate you trying to keep me safe, but I don’t need you right now. I’ll call upon you when I do.” 

When you pay attention and observe your own behaviors that you don’t like, it doesn’t really feel good. This can spark your inner critic that engages in unhelpful negative self-talk.

Saying “no” and learning how to set boundaries can be difficult. Having a therapist that you have a good relationship with, that you feel comfortable with and can trust, sets a good foundation for practicing these strategies.

I often encourage clients to set boundaries in session. For example, if they need to end a session 10 minutes early, or not wanting to talk about something heavy or traumatic because they have a fun dinner right after session. I find it a marker of strength and tremendous personal growth when my clients speak up for what they need. 

In addition, spending years in survival mode can also have an impact on so many other things. It can impact your well-being, physical and emotional health, the ability to be present, and even memories. This can result in you finding it hard to access your true self—and what your wants and needs really are.